Your Deductible After a Collision: How It Actually Works

The deductible is the part of a claim you pay yourself, and the confusion is rarely about the amount. It is about when it applies and who eventually bears it.

The basic position

If you claim on your own collision cover, you pay the deductible and the insurer pays the rest. The shop collects it from you, usually when you collect the car.

When the other driver was at fault

There are two routes. Claim against their insurer directly, in which case there is normally no deductible but the process can be slower while liability is established. Or claim on your own policy, pay your deductible, and let your insurer recover from theirs through subrogation. If that recovery succeeds, your deductible is generally refunded, sometimes in proportion to the share of fault.

Why people choose the slower route

Because paying nothing now is attractive. It is worth weighing against the delay: a car sitting unrepaired while liability is argued is a car accruing rental costs and, if it is stored somewhere, storage.

Comprehensive claims

Hail, theft, vandalism and falling objects usually fall under comprehensive rather than collision, and the deductible is often lower. Glass is sometimes covered separately with a small deductible or none at all. See glass replacement and repair.

What not to do

Do not ask a shop to absorb or waive your deductible by inflating the estimate. It is insurance fraud, it exposes you as well as the shop, and any shop willing to do it is telling you how it treats the rest of its work.

Plan for it

Know your number before you need it, and know whether it differs between collision and comprehensive. It is the one figure in the policy that affects every claim you make.

Insurance claim repair at A1 Collision NY.

Related: insurance claim repair and collision repair.